Questions can be posed on this discussion by a member, or posted to a ZetaTalk Question email address. Nancy will then post all accepted email questions from the general public to this discussion.

  • Twitter: @NancyLieder1
  • If your questions are just a demand for a hand-held tour, and it is apparent you have not even attempted to research or read the existing material, your post will be deleted.
  • Commentary chitchat will automatically be deleted if it does not add to the questions already posed. The weekly Q&A chat is not a stage for opinions or rants.
  • Research the ZetaTalk WebSite and use the Search Engine dedicated to the site. Check the prior ning chats archives or the prior GLP chat archives. This Search Tips Primer will make you an expert after only a quick read.

Accepted questions will be noted as such.

  • If Nancy indicates that your question is “accepted” then it will be answered.
  • If not, assume it has been declined by the Zetas.
  • The Q&A discussions just past and ongoing are pinned for easy reference.
  • Answers will be posted by Saturday Noon EST. The discussion will be closed Friday morning with a new discussion opened for the following week at that time.
  • To find all prior chats on the ning, go to this list:

Ning Rules that Apply

  1. No debunking and disruption. Debunking and disruption will lead to suspension.
  2. The existence of Planet X and the truthfulness of ZetaTalk are not debatable.
  3. This ning does not focus on religion or politics, so these types of questions will be declined as a distraction from the issue at hand.
  4. ZetaTalk only. Posting of or discussion regarding material alleged to be channeled or otherwise relayed by entities other than the STO Zetas to anyone other than Nancy Lieder of is not allowed on this site

Zeta Rules that Apply

  1. No personal counseling is done.This rule has been in place since 1996. Questions should be of broad interest to the general public.
  2. Correlation or resolution of ZetaTalk with the work of other channels or authors is not done unless they predict and have a prediction accuracy track record, as otherwise they are not a peer of ZetaTalk which does so. This rule has been in place since 2002. Just because another website or author makes a statement does not make that statement true, nor will the Zetas explain to you why their statements are not true, as then they are taking time out to address the issue.
  3. The Zetas, as all visitors, are under rules on how they interact with humanity. They are not here to rescue you. They cannot divert Planet X just as today they do not prevent droughts or floods. The Earth is mankind’s schoolhouse whereby he learns to help his fellow man.
  4. The date of the pole shift cannot be given, but the sequence of events can be given. [ Link ] Check the ning pinned discussions and blogs for such information as the 7 of 10, the last weeks, etc.

Note the Zeta's words on wasting the opportunity to pose question to themselves, and get a response via Nancy. They do not suffer fools gladly, and this will increasingly be the case.

This is an opportunity to discuss the public's expectations of Nancy, who is a single person, 70 [73] years old, with health concerns, who works every day for as many hours as her health allows on getting the message out to the world. She was asked, in the early days of ZetaTalk, to be as educated on astronomy as astronomers, and did so to a degree that allowed her to support the imaging of the inbound Planet X. She supported our debates on sci.astro on the absurdity of human math when faced with reality, on the matter of why the Moon is in the skies and not crashing to Earth, even though she does not speak math any more than she speaks Greek. To properly translate our concepts, Nancy, as she has so often mentioned, must be on the same page as ourselves, versed sufficiently in the subject to understand our response. Thus she has been asked to be educated to the level of a biologist or geneticist on the matter of the hybrids, to be a geologist on plate movements, to be a vulcanologist, to be a hydrologist on water movement, to be an archeologist re ancient civilizations, to be an electrician when discussing survival equipment, and to be a sociologist and political scientist on the matter of human behavior. Where images do not exist on the web, she draws them sufficiently to explain our words. We do not, on every answer, require Nancy to spend hours positioning herself such that she goes beyond what is needed to relay our message.

Bear in mind, during these chats, what you are asking of ourselves and Nancy. You have a resource here which you are regularly wasting and exhausting with idiotic questions! Nancy has warned that the time is quickly coming when you will get no response from her at all, just a statement as to which questions will be accepted. You have complained when she told you, in no uncertain terms, what was wrong with your demands or your questions. But those who do not learn are destined to be ignored, which is what is coming next.

Views: 12649

Replies are closed for this discussion.

Replies to This Discussion

Accepted via email:

Is this Nibiru capture, as Marshall Masters claims?
[and from another]
April 23, 2015. In a live, predawn telecast on or about January 14, 2014, the morning news anchors of this NBC News affiliate, KCRA in Sacramento, CA aired live video from their own KCRA new helicopter. In it, they reported an observation of a planet they could not explain.

Marshall is famous for pointing to a spec of volcanic dust and a smear
on a webcam glass cover as being objects far out in space. As can be clearly seen in the videos provided by Masters, these objects do NOT MOVE with the Sun but remain stationary
in relation to the horizon. The spec of volcanic dust even stands on the lens when the horizon is black with volcanic dust uprising. This is out in space?  Masters goes through contortions
to explain all of this in his bid to be the leader during the Nibiru announcement, but fails.

Now we have another disaster by Masters, who has produced a new video with claims that KCRA captured Venus eclipsing Nibiru in the pre-dawn hours on January 14, 2014. What is wrong with his claims? The KCRA team concludes that it is Venus occulting Saturn, which is correct. Per Skymap, Saturn and Venus should not be in the same line of sight for an occultation. But the Earth is in a halted orbit, not yet admitted by the establishment, and thus is farther back in her orbit, so that both planets would thus appear in the same line of sight.

That this is Saturn is also shown by the bright orb in the occulting pair being a tiny spec when the camera zooms away, a pinpoint. Nibiru captured daily lately
on an Italian webcam is showing its true size when viewed from Earth. Not a pinpoint. Nibiru is also too closely shrouded by red dust to be seen as a bright orb with clearly defined edges. Then there is the issue of size. Nibiru is described by Harrington as being five times the diameter of Earth. We, the Zetas, state it is four times the diameter. Both Venus and Earth are the same size, yet in the occultation Venus can be seen AS LARGE as the planet it is occulting.

Masters may claim it is Nibiru at a distance, but then why is this version of Nibiru not seen daily, pre-dawn, around the world? And why is Saturn seen, at a distance, daily, at this location? KCRA is correct, it is Saturn being occulted. Master’s fails once again. But hear him roar, and oh, by the way, buy his books and DVDs.

Prior ZT:
Marshall Masters of YOWUSA is one who did not deny that Planet X existed, but attempted to ally with the cover-up by claiming it was out in space somewhere, at an undetermined location. He also has claimed that the myriad photos, videos, and SOHO images of the Planet X complex showing its location all these years are a result of cheap cameras or lens flares. Everyone is mistaken, except for Marshall Masters and his supposed team of experts.

Any comments: Earthquake Nepal, Killing More Than 2300

Declined as it is obvious. If you type in Indo-Australian Plate the Brake into the Search Engine you will find that we have FOREVER been emphasizing that this hammering under the Himalayas would occur, the culmination the Pole Shift time when India will be shoved down, along with 2/3 of Australia. The Himalayas are the highest peaks for this reason. Written in the geography! Read the 7 of 10 plate movements and what starts it all. The Zetas have asked that for every earthquake, they not get the query "what does this mean" and lately for every dashing dot in the skies "is this a UFO", or for every capture of Planet X or the Moon Swirls "is this Planet X". We have to address the cutting edge, save our energies for that, and you are asking for us to repeat the obvious and forever/often stated! Soon Q&A will be closed for good, during the uptick and media attention after the announcement. You have only yourself to blame for making the chat irrelevant!

Rustam said:

Any comments: Earthquake Nepal, Killing More Than 2300

Accepted via email as this is NEW material not covered yet by ZT:

If dragons and vampire bats and the Devil were real extra-terrestrial creatures, was Yoda real too?
[and from another]
Was Yoda a Medieval Monk?
April 16, 2015
The force is strong with this one: this pre-1600 Yoda lookalike was found on a Medieval manuscript. Photograph: British Library - a doodled figure, which looks curiously like Yoda from Star Wars.

Is the Star Wars creature known as Yoda a real creature? Yes, with a home planet that is close enough to Earth’s environment that visitations to Earth are possible. We have mentioned that many authors and producers are contactees, introduced to many of the life forms that humans might encounter during contact so that these might be included in stories or movies. Prior to the days of Roswell, encounters with extra-terrestrials were recorded in the conscious of man, such that descriptions of the Devil,
depictions in the Vedas,
and alien life forms such as the Pig Dragon assisting the Annunaki
are correctly described in appearance and manner.

The Yoda hominoid is still in service during the Earth’s Transformation. They are solidly Service-to-Other and prefer a quiet behind-the-scenes role, thus the role as a monk in human society was quite fitting – a counselor, rather than a politicians. But as depicted in Star Wars, the Yoda group is hardly timid or acquiescing. They draw the line firmly when encountering Service-to-Self motives and will go into battle if need be.  Thus they limit their activity during contact to working with those humans who are engaged in battles, helping them discern when a passive or active role would be most effective.

Question for the Zs:
What was the motive behind this cyber attack on the Mauna Kea telescope observatory?

Accepted. There is something suspicious about this.

Joseph said:

What was the motive behind this cyber attack on the Mauna Kea telescope observatory?

[and from another]
The summit of Mauna Kea on the Island of Hawaii hosts the world's largest astronomical observatory, with telescopes operated by astronomers from eleven countries. The combined light-gathering power of the telescopes on Mauna Kea is fifteen times greater than that of the Palomar telescope in California -- for many years the world's largest -- and sixty times greater than that of the Hubble Space Telescope. Mauna Kea is unique as an astronomical observing site. The atmosphere above the mountain is extremely dry -- which is important in measuring infrared and submillimeter radiation from celestial sources - and cloud-free, so that the proportion of clear nights is among the highest in the world. The exceptional stability of the atmosphere above Mauna Kea permits more detailed studies than are possible elsewhere, while its distance from city lights and a strong island-wide lighting ordinance ensure an extremely dark sky, allowing observation of the faintest galaxies that lie at the very edge of the observable Universe.
[and from another]
Native Hawaiians are protesting the new Mauna Kea telescope, the Thirty-Meter Telescope. The Mauna Kea telescope project has caused the protesters to travel to the area to dispute its creation due to the sacredness of the Mauna Kea or Mauna O Wakea Mountain. Mauna Kea is considered by the natives as the most sacred place in the entire Hawaiian archipelago because of the belief that several Hawaiian gods live on its peak.
[and from another]
It appears the stars have not yet aligned for the Thirty Meter Telescope project, which saw its main website targeted by an alleged cyberattack this weekend. The site was unavailable for several hours, a project spokesperson confirmed, and a group known as Operation Green Rights--associated with the popular Anonymous movement--has claimed responsibility. Despite approval from the state's Board of Land and Natural Resources in 2013, the TMT project has run into opposition since the site was first selected in 2009. Objections come from both native Hawaiians, to whom Mauna Kea is a sacred site, and environmental advocates, as they believe the telescope's construction will interfere with Mauna Kea's glacial ecosystem and perhaps put native species at risk.

Where on the surface this cyberattack looks like support for the long-running complaints by native Hawaiians about their sacred mountain top – Mauna Kea – being used for observatories, this is not the basis for the cyberattack. Mauna Kea supports the largest telescopes on the face of the Earth, with great clarity as the atmosphere above the clouds there is clear and dry and free of pollution. Larger and larger observatories have thus been placed there, and as Nibiru draws close peering out into sky for infra-red captures has become increasingly important. Nibiru and its dominant Moon Swirls can be distinctly outlined in infra-red.

Less than a month ago we were asked to comment on the Executive Order Obama wrote declaring cyber-security a potential National Emergency. Our explanation was that Obama is anticipating the cover-up crowd shifting to blocking the media or other information sources after they LOSE the battle to block the announcement. Yes, Nibiru is approaching for a passage, but only the cover-up crowd will tell you what this means. No ZetaTalk prophecy. No honest information on how close it is coming from any observatory. Lies of every kind on what is causing the Earth changes. The cover-up, in essence, will continue, or so they hope.

Images from Mauna Kea are anticipated to be highly sought after, as outside of images from the ISS or from probes sent aloft to peek at the approaching Nibiru, these will have the greatest clarity of any observatory on Earth. The cyberattack was a warning from the elite wanting the cover-up over the approach of Nibiru to continue, in whatever fashion. Will this type of intimidation succeed? Hardly. Obama has already gone on record stating that this type of activity will be treated as a CRIME, of the highest order. In that a front operation is being used, it is the behind the scenes prosecution by black ops that will address these crimes. The people have a right to know. This is Obama’s attitude.   

Prior ZT:
Why would an Executive Order on cyber-security be necessary at this time? Hacking of government websites and databases has long been an issue. Where Obama and his announcement team have had to work to get access to the Emergency Alert System, long blocked by the cover-up crowd to prevent him from making his announcement, the war in this regard will shortly be over. The worry will shift to use of the Internet and various fuming media outlets with a vested interest in the status quo that will try to control the information the public gets in order to arrange their private kingdoms. It is this that will result in a heavy handed federal response. 

Hi Nancy,


A question regarding these reported UFO sightings:

In light of the recent quake in Nepal, are these UFO's somehow warning the residents of low lying Pampanga to prepare for a similar event?

Pampanga is around the area where the Philippine plate breaks with the Eurasian plate:


Joseph, You should expect an earthquake they've been there recently. Magnitude 6.2 earthquake strikes parts of NCR, Luzon Mild quake hits Pampanga town But then again you have to understand that it is impossible to predict.

Hi Nancy and Zetas,

In 2012 the Zetas were asked to learn about the plans of governments on the Pole Shift. They said that all the government has no plans to move or at least as something to help in times of disaster. (with the exception of Sweden and China) ZetaTalk Chat Q&A for February 4, 2012

Since then, the situation has changed and we know the position of many countries. Such as Australia could become an authoritarian country. ZetaTalk Chat Q&A for August 23, 2014

But all the position of many countries is unknown, and whether to expect "repression."

For example situation in Asia. Recently the post of the President of Indonesia was elected Joko Widodo.

Profile: Joko Widodo
Joko Widodo - also known as Jokowi - is a popular figure with the Indonesian public, supported by young people in both urban and rural areas, who see him as a clean politician in a country beset by corruption, reports BBC Indonesian's Sri Lestari.

In 2010, he was elected for second term with more than 90% of the vote, as people supported policies aimed at boosting small and local businesses.
He rebuilt traditional markets and relocated poor people who lived on the river banks to proper houses.
He then captured national attention when he traded in his regular car for an Esemka - a local vehicle manufactured by a high school team in Solo.
Mr Widodo then went on to run for the position of Jakarta's governor, winning a resounding victory in 2012. He is seen as a man who has the ability to empathise with the poor.
"For me, democracy means listening to the people, and doing what they want me to do," he said during the first televised presidential debate. Source:

Will it have it to change the situation in Indonesia?

ZetaTalk prediction:

When it becomes apparent to the hands of power in countries currently ruling with repression that violent earth changes are close at hand, they will do more than simply suppress news of coming changes and seek a timely escape to safe places for themselves, they will also prevent escape for their populace to the extent this disrupts their own plans. The regimes likely to take these steps, and their responses and reasons for taking these steps, vary:

Indonesia has been much in the news in past years for its severe repression, to the point of brutal slaughter, of its populace. East Timor has only recently won the right as a country, not in Indonesia to be free of utter brutality at the hands of the Indonesian military. The rules of war, where a country to be invaded is treated as a combatant and civilians treated under different rules than combatants were not even considered. Genocide, of the weak and helpless first, was the rule. How will such a dictatorship, with such a military in command, react when it becomes evident that Earth changes in keeping with our predictions are eminent? The wealthy and powerful will have already lined up an escape to safer lands, or will already be there. As we have predicted this will be toward Australia, to the degree that this country allows such immigration, and in that Australia is already putting up blocks to immigration by the common man, it can be expected that a quid pro quo will be asked of the Indonesian elite - you may enter, but only if you block the human tide expected to follow you. Thus, in Indonesia, the populace will be locked from boats in the harbors, blocked from airports, and even blocked from escape into their highlands! The goal will be to not only prevent the populace from invading Australia, but to create as massive a dieoff as possible, so that survivors do not go afloat in boats and land on the shores of Australia as flotsam, afterwards. Soldiers unaware of what is coming can be expected to comply with these orders, but when it becomes apparent, such as during the rotation stoppage, that they will be impacted likewise, they will leave their posts and join the masses seeking escape of some kind.
Noted for its brutal repression of democratic sentiment during the Pinochet era, where citizens were kidnapped and tortured for the mere offense of thinking about fair play or appearing likely to even have such thoughts, Chile has not made much progress in the intervening years. The military, the guilty, are still protected, forgiven by a court system in sympathy with past oppression and new governance fearful of a return to these times when the strong arm ruled without restraint. Many Nazi escaped to South America when WW II turned the tide for them, and this tenor of elitism still reigns in the halls of power in there, though not openly expressed. One can see the role Chile will play in Margaret Thacher’s forgiveness of Pinochet when he was captured while in Europe for heath care. As we have mentioned, the elite in Britain plan to vacate their country, going to Australia, prior to the shift, but a card that might be played is an exodus to Chile, and thus she was carefully retaining her options. These countries will find bridges and transportation broken utterly, after the shift, all on foot or horseback and not able to travel far. Thus, the elite will soon find themselves starving, but unable to raid more than the immediate area. This will create infighting, as we have described, with the strong and brutal toying with and eliminating those whothought they were in power. Money will mean nothing, and threats of court action or imprisonment for defying orders likewise meaningless. Thus, these pockets of elitism will become decimated, going the way of thugs locked into interaction with each other, usually a short and brutal existence.

ZetaTalk: Repressive Regimes

Also, many countries South American countries have become more democratic. For example Maduro in Venezuela.

In general question is what plans (in the general case) are in regions such as South America and South East Asia for the period after the announcement, and in the future on the Pole Shift? I would also like to ask whether we should expect that the army would kill "all" in countries such as North Korea? A recent example of a military coup in Thailand, makes us wonder what role in the future, will play army?


Declined as you have answered the question! Pampanga is on Luzon. The southern part of this large island moves with the Sunda Plate, the northern part is on the Philippine Plate. Thus it is tearing apart.

Manila has been held up by the fact that the Philippine Plate is tilting under it, but as the tilt increases, southern Luzon will act more like a city on the Sunda Plate and experience flooding.

Joseph said:

A question regarding these reported UFO sightings:

Stan thanks for researching the relevant. Where in 2012 the Zetas said that Russia had NO PLANS beyond guarding against migrants and protecting the Urals, that has changed big time.They have decreed that their state offices are to move the their Far East, and started developing these lands, encouraging the populace to move there. Russia is doing everything right!

"Beyond saving the elite, and moving the military resources to the Urals and to places along the southern borders to guard against an influx of refugees, Russia is making no plans. In truth, almost all countries are in a similar position. Sweden is planning to take steps to relocate its citizenry when coastal flooding becomes evident, but will remain mum about these plans until then."

It is clear that Australia has gotten MORE repressive, the Indonesian elite cooperative in this. Polarization can be expected, where the selfish and repressive get more so, the generous and helpful likewise more so.Beyond that, as the Zetas have said everytime asked this type of question, it is in the hands of man, who has free will. CANNOT be predicted. Look at the Arab Spring!Caused by walk-in spirits incarnating bodies with unsparked souls. Not predictable.

Stanislav said:

Also, many countries South American countries have become more democratic. For example Maduro in Venezuela.

In general question is what plans (in the general case) are in regions such as South America and South East Asia for the period after the announcement, and in the future on the Pole Shift? I would also like to ask whether we should expect that the army would kill "all" in countries such as North Korea? A recent example of a military coup in Thailand, makes us wonder what role in the future, will play army?

Could the Zetas say something to this latest crop circle. My feeling tells me it has to with timing/orbit ?


Gerard Zwaan said:

Could the Zetas say something to this latest crop circle.

Could the Zetas say something to this latest crop circle? My feeling tells me it has to with timing/orbit?
[and from another]
This modest design is describing the Earth’s stopped orbit and its relationship to Nibiru. The spiral in the center is to imply the Earth orbit, going round and round. The spiral outward implies the growing influence of Nibiru as it approached the inner solar system. The orb blocking the spiral, standing in the Earth’s orbit location, implies the point where Earth halted her orbit and began to back up. Nibiru’s influence is greatest at the hour of the Pole Shift, and thereafter it directly leaves the solar system, rapidly. It has scant lingering effects on the Earth during this exit.  


SEARCH PS Ning and Zetatalk



You can support the ning by using the above button. 


© 2017   Created by Gerard Zwaan.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service